Tax Court Opens Nine Years of Returns in Hee: Fraud Has No Clock
In Hee (T.C. Memo 2026-53), the Tax Court let the IRS audit 2004-2012 returns years past the normal deadline, finding fraud voids the statute of limitations entirely. The IRS won on all issues.

Adjustments
- Tax Court decided Hee, T.C. Memo 2026-53, on June 23, 2026.
- IRS examined nine tax years, 2004-2012, beyond the normal three-year limitations period.
- Fraud removes the statute of limitations entirely; returns can be challenged indefinitely.
- Six-year window applies only when gross income is understated by more than 25%.
- Taxpayer deducted children's wages, travel and a suit as business expenses; IRS won all issues.
A Hawaii businessman just lost nine years of audit protection. In Hee, T.C. Memo 2026-53, decided June 23, 2026, the Tax Court let the IRS examine tax years 2004 through 2012 — far beyond the normal statute of limitations — and sided with the government on every issue.
Why could the IRS reach back nine years?
The baseline rule is three years. The IRS generally has three years from a return's filing due date to challenge what's on it. A 2026 return due April 15, 2027, stays open until April 15, 2030. That window stretches to six years when gross income is understated by more than 25%.
Fraud breaks the clock entirely. Where the IRS establishes fraud, returns can be challenged indefinitely. Practitioners should treat the three-year window as protection against error, not against deceit — and should make sure clients understand the difference.
What did the taxpayer do?
The taxpayer, a Naval Academy graduate, was sole shareholder and president of several affiliated telecommunications companies. His routine looked ordinary at first: he paid both business and personal expenses on personal credit cards, then had his assistant sort the charges and reimburse him for corporate items.
The scheme came in the sorting. He misled his assistant and other recordkeeping staff so personal spending was coded as business, including:
- extensive travel expenses;
- wages and benefits paid to his children to cover college tuition, lodging and a home in Santa Clara — despite schedules showing the children could not plausibly have worked the hours claimed;
- the cost of a suit bought for a business meeting, despite the long-settled rule that attire suitable for everyday wear is not deductible.
How did the trial go?
Badly, and predictably. The taxpayer failed to give his accountants the records needed to support the deductions. At trial he offered what the court found to be flimsy explanations or ignored disputed items altogether. A trip abroad became a "succession planning" gathering; a family vacation was relabeled a "stockholder's meeting."
The court found insufficient substantiation or credible evidence that the returns for the years at issue were legitimate, even though the inquiry ran years past the normal limitations period. The IRS prevailed on all issues.
What does the ruling change for practitioners?
Nothing in the law; everything in the caution. The case is a clean restatement of the principle that the limitations clock never starts running against a taxpayer whose conduct constitutes fraud. Clients who recharacterize personal expenses, shift income-adjacent benefits to children, or starve their preparers of records are not aggressive planners — they are litigants in waiting.
The mechanics here are worth flagging in client conversations. The fraud exception neutralized the statute for nine consecutive tax years, 2004-2012. No contemporaneous substantiation meant no defense at trial. And labels — "succession planning," "stockholder's meeting" — carried no weight against the underlying facts.
The lesson the court handed down is blunt: the taxpayer did more than stretch the truth, he lied outright. The statute of limitations offers no shelter to taxpayers who show blatant disregard for the rules. Three years protects mistakes. It has never protected fabrication.
via CPA Practice Advisor (Source)
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in CPA News is a professional daily at CPA News.
6 articles
Linked entries
- IRS OPR Tells Firms to Notify Insurers in Breach Plans
- Form 122A-1 Income Is Not Return Income: The Crosswalk CPAs Need
- CP2100 Notices Land in April: Three W-9 Myths That Cost Payers
- Australia’s top 100 accounting firms post $15.6 billion revenue
- Goosehead stock falls 18% after SEC comment sparks restatement