FASB proposal could push community banks to sell mortgage servicing
A proposed FASB standard could pressure some community banks to sell mortgage-servicing portfolios, while exceptions remain contested over restoring uniform practice.

Adjustments
- A proposed FASB standard could push some community banks to sell mortgage-servicing portfolios because valuations would become more complex.
- PennyMac CFO Dan Perotti said exceptions could widen the practice diversity the project aimed to resolve.
- An unnamed company will pay $4.6 million to settle allegations involving pandemic-era foreclosure-protection rules.
- A Tuesday final rule from the Federal Reserve, OCC and FDIC lowers the community bank leverage ratio to 8% and softens demands for the largest banks.
- The CFPB has received more than 11,000 comments on personal financial data rights; banks want fintech partners to share compliance burdens.
A proposed Financial Accounting Standards Board accounting standard could push some community banks to sell mortgage-servicing portfolios because it complicates asset valuations, according to National Mortgage News.
The source describes a potential transaction trigger, not a mandatory divestiture. It does not identify the proposal number, affected paragraph, effective date, transition period, measurement mechanics, affected dollar balances or the number of banks considering sales. The available record supports none of those details.
Possibility, not command.
Dan Perotti, CFO of PennyMac Financial Services, wrote that allowing exceptions “would preserve, and in our view could widen, the diversity in practice the project was undertaken to resolve.”
Perotti’s objection is direct: exceptions could leave banks applying divergent practices after the project set out to resolve that diversity. Any carve-out therefore risks reintroducing the inconsistency the accounting project was meant to remove.
Exceptions carry the risk.
What does the proposal change for community banks?
The proposal would complicate mortgage-servicing valuations for some financial institutions, the source’s stated key issue. For a community bank that owns a servicing portfolio, that complexity can make continued ownership less attractive than a sale. The reported effect is pressure, not an order.
The source identifies Ron Haynie, senior vice president of mortgage finance policy at the Independent Community Bankers of America, in connection with the proposal. It supplies no direct statement from him, so his position cannot be stated further from the available text.
The source provides no servicing-portfolio balance, gain-on-sale estimate, capital effect or implementation timetable. It also does not say that ICBA, PennyMac or any community bank has ordered a sale. The defensible conclusion is narrower: the proposal could increase pressure to sell where valuation becomes harder to manage.
The FASB measure remains a proposal in the source, unlike the leverage measure described as final. That status matters. A proposal can prompt portfolio review; it does not establish a disposal mandate on this record.
How should bankers read the effect?
Read it as a valuation and ownership issue, not a settled disposal requirement. Banks have no disclosed sale deadline in the source, and the proposal details needed to model portfolio-level outcomes remain unspecified. A board should not convert a possible market effect into a definite transaction plan without the missing accounting and timing information.
Without those details, an institution cannot calculate a sale threshold, effective-date impact or portfolio valuation change from the source alone. Neither Perotti nor the source presents an exception as settled. The quoted language is a warning about outcomes, not a description of an adopted carve-out.
What else changed in the regulatory record?
- $4.6 million foreclosure settlement. An unnamed company will pay that amount to resolve allegations that it violated foreclosure-protection rules in place during the pandemic. The source does not identify the company or regulator.
- 8% community-bank leverage ratio. On Tuesday, the Federal Reserve, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency and Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. issued a final rule softening leverage demands for the largest, most systemically risky banks and lowering the community bank ratio to 8%.
- Burden objections. Bank industry advocates, housing groups and CRA veterans called the final rule overly complex and burdensome. Even those critics agreed that pre-approving CRA-eligible activities was a good idea.
- More than 11,000 data-rights comments. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has received that many comment letters on its personal financial data rights proposal. Banks say the CFPB should ensure more fintech partners take on their fair share of compliance burdens.
The settlement concerns foreclosure protections; the leverage rule concerns balance-sheet requirements; the data-rights proposal concerns access to personal financial information. None supplies a missing detail for the proposed servicing standard.
The source’s regulatory record spans 1 proposed accounting standard, 1 $4.6 million settlement, 1 final leverage rule with an 8% community-bank ratio and 1 data-rights proposal with more than 11,000 comments. Only the FASB item directly raises the prospect of servicing sales, and it does not establish a mandate.
via Google News · FASB PCAOB AICPA (Source)
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in CPA News is a professional daily at CPA News.
3 articles
Linked entries
- SEC SOX proposal could exempt 1,596 companies from 404(b) attestation
- PCAOB seeks comfort-letter feedback, creates 5 enforcement units
- Sri Lanka Bars Two EY Partners From Bank Audits After $41 Million NDB Fraud
- FASAB reopens federal environmental cleanup liability rules
- PCAOB Creates Five Audit-Misconduct Units as Budget Falls 9.4%