Firms

AI Is Killing the Big Four's Advice-Selling Business, KPMG Says

KPMG's global consulting head says AI has made advice-selling "literally nonexistent." Clients from UniCredit to Bayer are cutting spend as firms rewrite billing, partner pay and training.

The Big Four’s AI Reckoning: A Business Model Under Pressure - https://www.big4news.com/
Exhibit · The Big Four’s AI Reckoning: A Business Model Under Pressure - https://www.big4news.com/ — Leonhard_Niederwimmer / pixabay

Adjustments

  1. KPMG's Svilena Tzekova said on 12 November that AI has made advice-selling 'literally nonexistent' as a revenue line.
  2. UniCredit cut consulting spend 24% in H1 2026; Société Générale 9%; Commerzbank targets €500m annual savings from a €600m AI investment.
  3. Clients expecting to increase Big Four use fell from 80% to 55% year-on-year (Source Global/FT), though tech consulting spend is seen at $420bn in 2026.
  4. McKinsey's Project Acorn raises equity-retained partner awards by an estimated 3-5 percentage points; PwC's US-India venture covers ~40,000 staff by H1 2027.
  5. PwC is investing over $100m in critical-thinking certification for 85,000+ employees from December 2026; a KPMG/UT Austin study found 24.1% of juniors performed worse than AI agents alone.

"We were making quite a lot of money by providing advice. I think that part of our business is literally nonexistent anymore." That admission came from Svilena Tzekova, KPMG's global head of consulting, in a 12 November interview with CNBC — the sharpest acknowledgment yet that artificial intelligence is dismantling a core revenue engine of the Big Four.

Tzekova explained that clients can now obtain knowledge and advice that previously required days or months of consulting work. Her comment crystallises pressure on a decades-old model: partners sell engagements while pyramids of junior consultants research, analyse data and build deliverables, generating billable revenue at scale.

What do the clients' numbers show?

A Financial Times investigation found corporate clients demanding lower fees, bringing work in-house and cutting reliance on large consulting teams. The evidence is already in the results.

  • At Bayer, 30 AI agents support coding and testing during a six-year SAP transformation; project lead Jochen Kamp expects fewer consultants as a result.
  • UniCredit cut consulting expenditure 24% in the first half of 2026; Société Générale reported a 9% decline. Neither bank isolated how much stemmed directly from AI.
  • Commerzbank plans to invest €600 million in AI by 2030, targeting €500 million in annual savings, partly through lower consulting costs.
  • Source Global research cited by the FT shows the share of surveyed clients expecting to increase Big Four usage over the following 12 months fell from 80% to 55%.

Demand is not collapsing. Source Global estimated technology-consulting spending will reach $420 billion in 2026, up 8% on the prior year.

What does this change for billable hours?

Tzekova told CNBC that clients increasingly want to pay for results, yet many procurement departments still compare firms on hourly rates and staffing levels. Outcome-based contracts (fees linked to measurable improvements such as cost reductions or productivity gains) create their own problems: measuring results, isolating a firm's contribution and pricing the risk of failure. AI also adds costs — computing power, subscriptions and usage-based vendor charges.

Smaller rivals scent an opening. Emiko Caerlewy-Smith of London-based Elixirr told CNBC her firm prices deliverables and outcomes rather than hours, and argued boutique firms adapt faster than networks employing tens of thousands.

How are the firms responding?

McKinsey is overhauling partner compensation under Project Acorn, the FT reported in May. The initiative would increase the share of certain partner awards retained as equity by an estimated three to five percentage points, strengthening capital reserves, and bring forward payments to younger partners who previously waited years for performance-linked compensation. The changes took more than two years to develop. The shift matters because performance-linked fees can delay payment long after costs are incurred, forcing partnerships to retain more capital rather than distributing profits annually.

PwC US and PwC India have agreed to combine substantial parts of their consulting operations in a joint venture of approximately 40,000 people, merging PwC US's India-based Acceleration Centres with PwC India's consulting business. PwC US would hold majority voting rights; PwC India chair Sanjeev Krishan would serve as chief executive. Completion is expected in the first half of 2027, subject to regulatory approvals. PwC US chief executive Paul Griggs told the FT the future lies in AI-enabled managed services rather than labour-intensive outsourcing; Krishan counters that AI adoption may increase outsourcing demand for specialist technology expertise.

Who trains the next generation?

The pyramid has doubled as a training system, and that function is under strain. EY's global assurance innovation and digital leader, Paul Goodhew, told CNBC AI can handle preliminary tasks traditionally assigned to junior auditors, such as checking figures against supporting documents.

Tzekova does not favour abandoning graduate recruitment; she expects juniors to take responsibility earlier, provided they gain enough practical experience. The firms are retooling accordingly:

  • KPMG US redesigned its audit internship in July, sending nearly 1,000 interns to KPMG Lakehouse for exercises in fraud detection, investigating anomalies and questioning credible-seeming conclusions.
  • KPMG and the University of Texas at Austin studied 523 early-career professionals working with AI agents: 50.1% beat the AI's performance, 25.8% matched it and 24.1% performed worse than the AI alone.
  • EY's Career Residency will let selected assurance interns work part-time for eight to 12 months while finishing university; the first participants begin in January 2028.
  • PwC will spend more than $100 million on a critical-thinking certification for over 85,000 employees, using simulations to challenge AI-generated conclusions, starting December 2026.
  • In September, EY US launched a $100 million rewards programme recognising judgement, adaptability and collaboration alongside technology adoption.

Can the pyramid survive?

Griggs warned in a March FT interview that partners resisting AI have no long-term future at PwC. The firm introduced PwC One, a platform offering automated tax and consulting services priced by subscription or usage rather than hours, and will assess senior professionals on revenue and margin per employee rather than AI usage frequency.

In Big4News Expert Voices contributions, former Arthur Andersen professional William Englehaupt argued firms must rethink training, staffing and promotion structures together, while academic Patrick Rose flagged the risk of firms hitting measurable targets while losing the judgement those measures were meant to support. The open question: whether the Big Four can preserve the career structure that produces senior professionals while reducing dependence on the junior work that has traditionally funded it.

via Google News · Big Four (Source)

Share this article:

More from Priya Raman

Priya Raman

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering technology and product news in CPA News is a professional daily at CPA News.

9 articles

Linked entries

  1. 74% of AI-Using Clients Would Fact-Check Their Accountant's Work
  2. Big Four expand India deal teams as 2025 transactions hit 3,855
  3. Australia’s top 100 accounting firms post $15.6 billion revenue
  4. EY's 300-Partner India Deals Practice Now Largest in Its Global Network
  5. PCAOB Creates Five Audit-Misconduct Units as Budget Falls 9.4%

▲ Previous article