Firms

58% of CPA Firm Owners Now Fiercely Opposed to Private Equity

58.1% of CPA firm owners now call themselves decidedly opposed to private equity, up from 49.5% in June, as fears over independence and brand damage harden, the CPA PE Deal Tracker finds.

PE’s Fiercest Opponents Draw the Line on Integrity, Independence, Objectivity
Exhibit · PE’s Fiercest Opponents Draw the Line on Integrity, Independence, Objectivity — cloudhoreca / pixabay

Adjustments

  1. 58.1% of CPA firm owners are now 'decidedly opposed' to PE, up from 49.5% in June.
  2. 67.4% of opponents expect investor influence to threaten independence, vs. 37.1% of others.
  3. Only 4.2% of surveyed owners have taken or are seeking PE buyouts; 37.7% are wait-and-see.
  4. 70.5% of opponents fear CPA brand damage; 63.2% expect quality to decline under cost pressures.

Fifty-eight point one percent of CPA firm owners now describe themselves as “decidedly opposed and fiercely independent” on private equity — up from 49.5 percent in June, according to the new CPA Trendlines CPA PE Deal Tracker survey of rank-and-file owners.

The shift is sharp. What CPA Trendlines previously called “a bare but discernible majority” of CPAs open to PE has become a clear, measurable minority. Meanwhile, PE's takeover of the CPA business keeps spreading from the largest national firms to Main Street practices.

The remainder of the profession splits unevenly: 37.7 percent are waiting and thinking, and 4.2 percent have taken or are actively seeking PE buyouts.

What worries the opponents most?

Independence is the most dividing line. Among the fiercely independent, 67.4 percent expect investor influence to threaten independence or objectivity. Among everyone else — from owners who have done a deal to those who could be persuaded — only 37.1 percent share that concern.

The CPA brand draws the widest worry. Some 70.5 percent of opponents fear damage to the brand, against 41.9 percent of the rest. Reduced service quality from cost and commercial pressures concerns 63.2 percent of opponents versus 33.9 percent of others.

“PE will weaken the brand and may eliminate the attestation function and public interest that the CPA has been an advocate for,” said John Lawson, managing shareholder at SDK CPAs.

On higher-risk advice, the gap narrows but persists: 37.9 percent of opponents expect PE to push more aggressive advice, compared with 12.9 percent of other respondents.

Is one generation cashing out at the next one's expense?

Partnership economics opens another fault line. Among opponents, 30.5 percent expect PE to enrich current partners in the short term at the expense of future partners. Only 12.9 percent of other respondents share that worry.

“It seems like it is a way for older partners to cash out and disadvantage managers and newer partners (capping their upside),” said a partner at a local firm.

Not everyone reads the math that way. “Valuations have increased greatly, and our work as partners growing our recurring revenue is being valued,” said Anthony Sabella, managing partner at Sabella & Marshall CPAs, who sits in the wait-and-see camp.

Both assessments may hold. One prices the position of incoming partners; the other prices an established book. Notably, neither speaker belongs to the 4.2 percent actually pursuing a deal.

The prospect of partners becoming employees with less control and upside divides the groups less sharply: 46.3 percent of opponents cite it, against 38.7 percent of the rest. Another partner likens the trajectory to medicine, predicting employees “with less autonomy, less satisfaction and less flexibility.”

Where do the two camps agree?

Competitive effects produce far less division. The prospect that PE disadvantages smaller or non-PE firms draws 43.2 percent of opponents and 38.7 percent of others — a five-point spread, not a thirty-point one. Expectations of startups, spin-offs and breakaways are nearly identical: 16.8 percent versus 17.7 percent.

Dale Geeslin of Geeslin Group, who counts himself among the fiercely independent, anticipates a polarized market of “a few mega firms and smaller local firms.” His verdict is blunt: “The middle market will be underserved.”

Client attrition is already visible to some. “Every week we get new clients leaving because they don't know anyone, can't get anyone, and aren't getting good value,” said an opposed respondent in management at a local firm.

Opposition does not rule out operating gains. Faster adoption of advanced technology, including AI, is selected by 27.4 percent of opponents and 35.5 percent of others — the smallest gap in the survey. Both camps can read a balance sheet; they simply weigh the covenant differently.

via CPA Trendlines (Source)

Share this article:

More from Sophie Lindqvist

Sophie Lindqvist

Show full bio

Correspondent covering companies, deals and strategy in CPA News is a professional daily at CPA News.

7 articles

Linked entries

  1. Over Half of Practitioners Expect PE Deals to Erode Work Quality
  2. Accountants Forecast a Better 2027 Busy Season — Barely Seven Months After a Bad One
  3. SEC SOX proposal could exempt 1,596 companies from 404(b) attestation
  4. Goosehead stock falls 18% after SEC comment sparks restatement
  5. Big Four expand India deal teams as 2025 transactions hit 3,855

▲ Previous article